Propane in South Dayton

2 propane locations in South Dayton, NY.

Of the 2 propane locations listed in South Dayton, 1 offers tank exchange and 1 delivers.

Nearby cities in New York with listed propane: Fredonia (3 locations, about 15 mi), Dunkirk (4 locations, about 15 mi) and Falconer (4 locations, about 19 mi).

2 locations

AmeriGas Propane

524 Pine St, South Dayton, NY

Delivery

Tank exchange in South Dayton (1)

Stores listed by the exchange brands' own retailer locators as carrying swap cages for grill-size cylinders. A listing is not a stock check, so call ahead if you need a tank at a particular hour.

South Dayton Supermarket #39830

303 Pine St., South Dayton, NY 14138

Tank Exchange · Blue Rhino

Directions Call store

Listed in Blue Rhino's retailer locator, checked Sep 27, 2026.

Before you go

Refill vs. Tank Exchange: What You Actually Get

Exchange trades a tank; refill sells you gas by the gallon. The difference in what you get home with is larger than most people expect.

When Does a Propane Tank Expire?

Twelve years from the date stamped on the collar, then a requalification interval that depends on the test method. An out-of-date cylinder cannot legally be refilled.