Propane in Fayetteville

4 propane locations in Fayetteville, PA.

Of the 4 propane locations listed in Fayetteville, 4 offer tank exchange.

Nearby cities in Pennsylvania with listed propane: Chambersburg (24 locations, about 5 mi), Shippensburg (8 locations, about 10 mi) and Waynesboro (10 locations, about 11 mi).

4 locations

Tank exchange in Fayetteville (4)

Stores listed by the exchange brands' own retailer locators as carrying swap cages for grill-size cylinders. A listing is not a stock check, so call ahead if you need a tank at a particular hour.

Family Dollar #08662

4015 Lincoln Way E, Fayetteville, PA 17222

Tank Exchange · Blue Rhino

Directions Call store

Listed in Blue Rhino's retailer locator, checked Sep 27, 2026.

In N Out Beer

5455 Lincoln Hwy East, Fayetteville, PA 17222

Tank Exchange · Blue Rhino

Directions Call store

Listed in Blue Rhino's retailer locator, checked Sep 27, 2026.

Rutter's #05

6837 Lincoln Way East, Fayetteville, PA 17222

Tank Exchange · Blue Rhino

Directions Call store

Listed in Blue Rhino's retailer locator, checked Sep 27, 2026.

Rutter's #74

4030 Lincoln Way East, Fayetteville, PA 17222

Tank Exchange · Blue Rhino

Directions Call store

Listed in Blue Rhino's retailer locator, checked Sep 27, 2026.

Before you go

Refill vs. Tank Exchange: What You Actually Get

Exchange trades a tank; refill sells you gas by the gallon. The difference in what you get home with is larger than most people expect.

When Does a Propane Tank Expire?

Twelve years from the date stamped on the collar, then a requalification interval that depends on the test method. An out-of-date cylinder cannot legally be refilled.